Hi Rick,
Thanks for your interest.
My gripes with Spotlight may be mostly the result of not reading documents, Apple reports, etc. for its use. For example, I admit that I just learned that a double quote (“) placed before the word or words in the file name to be search for will get the search started looking for the TITLE desired. This is usually all I ask from a search.
However, occasionally I like to add other criteria & I find this trickier. I’ve been using the little share-ware, Spotlaser, which at least presents the searcher with most (all?) of the secondary criteria in a single window. It still seems clunky.
I have a secondary Firewire drive. For a couple of weeks after update to 10.4.4 I wasn’t able to search it. Now results from it show up — I’ve no idea why.
Smart Folders are nice — but not as nice as a fast, seamless, find.
By the way, when (if ever) is it necessary to have Spotlight re-index?
B.